logo
J.K. Rowling’s Super Weird, Bad, and Problematic Plot Points in Harry Potter (an Encyclopedic Rant)
Barely Sofia

207,142 views

5,773 likes

Ranting over the weird and problematic Harry Potter stuff because some of the stuff in these books is REALLY ODD.

Also, I obviously hate JKR, so that comes up a lot.

Credits:

This video was influenced by Shaun’s, Lily Simpson's, and Hoots Hootman's videos on Harry Potter. Some of the examples and arguments I cover overlap with theirs, and I’d recommend watching them.

In particular, I drew on Shaun’s video for the Kingsley Shacklebolt and Cho Chang naming arguments, the point about Hermione and the house-elves, the Mahoutokoro and Castelo Bruxo points, and the Kreacher sandwich line.

Shaun: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-1iaJWSwUZs&t=5601s

Lily Simpson: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N2WDCD_tRnE&t=208s

Hoots Hootman: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U3dE0sYZqvI&t=5s

I have become a Harry Potter Encyclopedia in the wake of this video, to my dismay, so I must hyperfixate on literally any other topic now, before the brain worms start reproducing.

------

00:00 INTRO

01:08 CHAPTER 1: Depictions of Race/Ethnicity

01:59 Kingsley Shacklebolt

03:28 Cho Chang

03:59 Dean Thomas

04:35 Blaise Zabini

04:51 Seamus Finnigan

05:36 Lee Jordan

06:03 Angelina Johnson

07:19 Fleur Delacour and the Veelas

08:19 The Goblins

08:59 Anthony Goldstein

10:12 The Other Schools

10:17 Durmstrang

11:08 Mahoutokoro

11:40 Uagadou

13:21 Castelo Bruxo

13:58 Ilvermorny

14:43 CHAPTER 2: Defending Slavery. (Yes. What the fuck.)

14:46 The House Elves

16:01 S.P.E.W.

17:19 Harry and Kreacher

18:11 INTERMISSION (Azkaban)

20:08 CHAPTER 3: Depictions of Disability, Disease and Addiction

20:11 Filch

20:47 The Werewolf Disease

22:21 Alcoholism

23:05 Weight and Obesity

25:37 CHAPTER 4: Depictions of Misogyny, Sexism and Gender Essentialism

25:41 Rita Skeeter

27:06 Gilderoy Lockhart

28:24 Nymphadora Tonks

28:34 Love Potions

29:49 Who gets to be "attractive"

31:27 The Motherhood Theme

33:12 CONCLUSION

#harrypotter