logo
What If Everything Went RIGHT for the Ottoman Empire?
Branchline History

8,032 views

91 likes

What if everything went right for the Ottoman Empire?

It's February 1878. A Russian army is closing in on Constantinople, the Ottoman Empire has just lost a war, and Sultan Abdulhamid II is about to shut his parliament for thirty years. In this video he doesn't. From that morning on, the empire uses what it already has in its own hand: a constitution it had proclaimed, a fleet it had paid for, promises it had signed, a war plan its own staff had written, and at the very end an offer in writing from the powers it was about to fight.

We lined those moments up as seven doors, and pinned to each one is a real paper from the day it stood open. The rule: the world outside stays exactly as hostile as it was. Same Russia, same Britain, same Balkan armies, same Great War. No lucky breaks and no enemy blunders. The empire only walks through a door when we can show you the paper that was on its own table. On one door the push is ours, and we say so. And one more door, standing in front of all seven, stays bricked shut.

So how far can a dying empire get on nothing but its own paperwork? Does it stay out of World War One? Does it keep Mecca, Jerusalem and Baghdad? Who ends up owning the oil? And if it all goes right for the empire, is that right for the people living inside it?

⏱ Chapters

0:00 Seven Doors

2:39 The Door That Stays Shut

4:19 Door One: The Parliament

6:33 Door Two: The Ships

8:28 Door Three: Egypt

10:47 Door Four: The Decree

13:12 The Sultan's Oil

15:05 Door Five: The Plan in the Drawer

18:04 Door Six: The Signature

20:26 Door Seven: The Guarantee

24:40 The Friday After

28:00 What the Oil Buys

30:03 Right for Whom

Our rule can't settle the last question, so we'd like your answer. Say it all goes right and the empire is still there. Which would you rather see on the map today: the empire, or the countries that replaced it? Tell us in the comments.

📄 Documents quoted in this video

The London Protocol and the Ottoman reply of 9 April 1877 · the dispatch of the American minister Horace Maynard, April 1877 · the Ottoman constitution of December 1876 · the Ottoman admiralty's fleet count of 1875 · the Sublime Porte's message to London of 26 July 1882 · the reform decree of 17 October 1895 · Kamil Pasha's memoirs · Ahmed Izzet Pasha's war plan of 1912 · the reform agreement of 8 February 1914 and the report of the Russian diplomat Gulkevich · the Grand Vizier's letter on the oil of Mosul and Baghdad, 28 June 1914 · Winston Churchill's reply to Cavid Bey, 1911 · Cavid Bey's diary, August 1914 · Sir Edward Grey's offer of a written guarantee, August 1914 · Enver Pasha's sealed order, October 1914 · Admiral Souchon's letter to his wife, 29 October 1914 · Talat Pasha's notebook.

📚 Historians and sources

Erik Zürcher, Şükrü Hanioğlu, Mustafa Aksakal, Michael Reynolds, Margaret Anderson, Ümit Kurt, Dilara Dal, Eugene Rogan, Sean McMeekin, Roderic Davison. Maps: Natural Earth (public domain); the coloured areas are approximate and drawn for the year shown on screen.

This video treats the massacres of the 1890s, Adana in 1909 and the Armenian Genocide of 1915 as part of the real history, with the figures historians give. Wherever a step is our own reading and not a document, we say so in the video.

Branchline History runs history again with one thing changed and every paper checked. Subscribe so you don't miss the next one.

#alternatehistory #ottomanempire #whatif