6,180 views
54 likes
James Hemings was Thomas Jefferson's chef and the older brother of Sally Hemings. Trained in the kitchens of Paris, he could have gone to a French court in 1789 and asked to be declared free. Instead he got into Jefferson's carriage on the Champs-Élysées on September 26, 1789, and went home to Virginia as a slave.
He was twenty-four, fluent in French, and the half-brother of Jefferson's late wife. In Paris he ran a kitchen of free French cooks while he himself was owned. Back in America he cooked for the Secretary of State in New York and Philadelphia, very likely including the dinner where the site of the nation's capital was bargained over. In 1793 he won a written promise of freedom from Jefferson, on one condition: he first had to train his younger brother Peter to take his place. He was freed in 1796, at thirty.
Five years later Jefferson became President and wanted his old chef back. James asked for one thing: a letter in Jefferson's own hand. The letter never came. Before the year was out, James Hemings was dead in Baltimore, at thirty-six, by his own hand. There is no portrait of him, no known date of death, no grave. The only page we have in his own handwriting is an inventory of the kitchen at Monticello.
If you had been James Hemings in Paris in 1789, would you have gone to the French court, or got into the carriage and gone home to your family? Tell us in the comments.
Chapters
0:00 Jefferson's Chef
1:44 The Last Autumn in Paris
4:13 A Family Inherited
6:59 The Body Servant
9:59 A Particular Purpose
11:58 The Kitchen of a Prince
15:16 Freedom If He Claims It
19:36 The Dinner Without a Cook
23:34 Six Months in Philadelphia
27:42 The Price of Freedom
31:01 A Journey to the Moon
36:18 The Tragical End
39:47 What the Kitchen Kept
Sources
Thomas Jefferson, agreement with James Hemings, September 15, 1793, and deed of manumission, February 5, 1796 (Albemarle County Deed Book 12).
James Hemings, inventory of kitchen utensils at Monticello, February 20, 1796.
Thomas Jefferson to Paul Bentalou, August 25, 1786.
Thomas Jefferson, "The Anas" (1818).
Isaac Jefferson, memoir dictated in 1847.
Madison Hemings, "Life Among the Lowly, No. 1", Pike County Republican, 1873.
Manasseh Cutler, Life, Journals and Correspondence (1888).
Mary Randolph, The Virginia House-Wife (1830 edition).
Monticello, Thomas Jefferson Encyclopedia, "James Hemings".
Lauren F. Klein, An Archive of Taste: Race and Eating in the Early United States (University of Minnesota Press, 2020).
Annette Gordon-Reed, The Hemingses of Monticello (2008), as quoted by other authors.
Virginia Scharff, "Sally Hemings (1773–1835)", Encyclopedia Virginia.
Patricia Bixler Reber, "James Hemings turns down Thomas Jefferson", Researching Food History (2018).
J. L. Bell, "A Kitchen for James Hemings", Boston 1775 (2018).
Willard Sterne Randall, "Thomas Jefferson Takes a Vacation", American Heritage (1996).
Maria Godoy, "Behind The Founding Foodie, A French-Trained Chef Bound By Slavery", NPR (2015).
Christina Tkacik, "Unearthing memories of James Hemings", Baltimore Sun (2022).
Images: public collections listed under Rights, reworked for this video. Full list of links on request in the comments.
Video: Pixabay.
Maps: Made with Natural Earth.
Rights
Archival images remain the property of their respective owners. They are used in edited form for historical commentary and education. If you are a rights holder and want an image credited differently or removed, write in the comments and we will respond promptly.
Public domain and CC0: Wikimedia Commons, The Metropolitan Museum of Art Open Access, Library of Congress, Historic American Buildings Survey, New York Public Library, Bibliothèque nationale de France, Paris Musées (Musée Carnavalet), Houghton Library, Natural Earth.
CC BY 2.0: "Kitchen area in lower level at Monticello", Bob from Allentown, Pennsylvania (Wikimedia Commons). CC BY 3.0: "Monticello dependencies on the south side of the house", David Broad (Wikimedia Commons).
Sound effects (Freesound): "20100402.Brugge.street.04.wav" by dobroide (CC BY 4.0), "Opening, closing door.WAV" by magnus589 (CC BY 4.0); other sounds CC0 by spanrucker, Sadiquecat, bolkmar, pflanigan, wwstudioswastaken, swiftoid, kbnevel, sechavez3499, puppetmaster685719, mpuffenbarger.
Pixabay Content License: Coverr-Free-Footage, Kaffeesüchtig, Kmeel_com, Life-Of-Vids, Matthias_Groeneveld, NickyPe, aghyadnajjar, mootlak.