175,759 views
2,323 likes
📌 Have you ever wondered what Grandpa did in World War II? If he never talked about it, his records can still tell you. Our step-by-step guide shows you how to find his unit, his medals and where he served.
To learn more, visit https://immersivepast.com
On 2 September 1991, sixty miles off New Jersey, a diver went down an anchor line toward a wreck that had no name. 230 feet down he found a submarine, and through an open hatch he could see a torpedo. It was a German U-boat from the Second World War, and no navy had any record of it: not the Americans, who had hunted U-boats along that coast, and not the Germans, who had lost it.
Finding out which boat it was took six years and cost three divers their lives. This video follows the clues the divers brought up from inside the wreck, from two china bowls and a dinner knife with a name cut into its handle to a tag on a box of spare parts, in a room no diver had ever entered. Then it asks the last question: what sank her?
WHAT THIS VIDEO COVERS
→ Labor Day 1991: Bill Nagle's dive boat, the Seeker, over a spot no diver had ever explored
→ Why 230 feet was the danger, when the recommended limit for sport diving is 130
→ John Chatterton finds her upright, torn open, her conning tower on the sand, her hatches open
→ Two china bowls with an eagle, a swastika and the year 1942
→ Some ten thousand attacks in the Navy's files, none at that spot: the U-Who
→ A dinner knife marked "Horenburg", and a boat recorded sunk 3,500 miles away
→ A plan of the ballast tanks: 1,171 U-boats narrowed to 36
→ Steve Feldman, then Chris Rouse and his son, Chris junior: the three divers the wreck killed
→ An escape lung's oxygen bottle and its test date: 36 boats narrowed to two
→ 1997: through a gap to the motor room, and the tag on a box of spare parts
→ The last patrol: a first-time captain, a radioman left in hospital, an order she never answered
→ How the record put her off Africa, and what the families were told
→ What sank her: her own torpedo, or two American escorts on 11 February 1945? Both accounts, and why neither is proved
→ Horst Bredow sees the tag, and the radioman who missed the patrol learns where his boat lies
CHAPTERS
00:00 Opening: 2 September 1991
00:49 The spot
02:10 Nineteen forty-two
03:51 A name on a knife
06:16 Thirty-six boats
08:39 A doubt in the files
10:23 The motor room
12:41 The last patrol
15:27 What sank her
19:44 The answer
SOURCES
Chatterton, Kohler and Yurga, "Final Report on the Location and Identification of the World War II German Submarine U-869" (1 March 1998). Yurga, Kohler and Chatterton, "The Fate of U-869 Reexamined", parts I-III, Wreck Diving Magazine 17-19 (2009). NOVA, "Hitler's Lost Sub" (PBS, 14 November 2000), and its interview with Herbert Guschewski. UPI, "U-boat discovered off New Jersey" (17 October 1991). Newhouse News Service, "World War II German U-Boat Found Off N.J. Coast", The Seattle Times (19 October 1991). uboat.net, U-869 (Guðmundur Helgason). uboatarchive.net, U-869: the Admiralty and U.S. Navy messages, December 1944 to March 1945, and the deck logs of USS Howard D. Crow and USS Koiner, 11 February 1945.
ARCHIVE AND CREDITS
Photographs and documents: U.S. Navy, U.S. Coast Guard and the two escorts' deck logs, most via the National Archives; National Security Agency; NOAA (D. Kesling; Joseph Hoyt); NASA. The crew of U-869 at her commissioning, January 1944: National Archives.
Bundesarchiv, Bild 101II-MW-1032-11A / Mannewitz; Bild 101II-MW-4222-01A, 101II-MW-5536-01 and 101II-MW-5536-03 / Dietrich; Bild 183-L15633 / SchĂĽtze; all CC-BY-SA 3.0.
Via Wikimedia Commons: James Loesch, "Manasquan Inlet aerial photograph 2022", CC BY 2.0; ArnoldReinhold, "U-505 submarine torpedo compartment with bunks", CC BY-SA 4.0; Ra Boe, "Cuxhaven -Altenbruch U Boot Archiv- 2008 by-RaBoe 001", CC BY-SA 2.5; Balcer, "Escape Set German Uboat", CC BY 2.5; ArildV, "Ministry of Defence Main Building Mars 2014", CC BY-SA 3.0; granuloman, "U-534 inside - panoramio", CC BY 3.0; Chris Allen, "U 534 - the motor room", CC BY-SA 2.0; Richard Hoare, "Section of Unterseeboot 534 (1) - Engine room", CC BY-SA 2.0; MonaLisa1998, "U-Boot-Ehrenmal Möltenort - Gedenktafeln", CC BY-SA 3.0; Holger.Ellgaard, "Heikendorf U-Boot Ehrenmal Bronzetafeln 2015", CC BY-SA 4.0; Rept0n1x, "T11 Zaunkonig 2 Torpedo", CC BY-SA 2.0; NOAA's National Ocean Service, "Photographing a German U-boat", CC BY 2.0; TeWeBs, "Laboe U995 Turmluk", CC BY-SA 4.0.
Film: U.S. Navy films, National Archives: the surrender of U-858 off Cape May (May 1945) and the capture of U-505 (June 1944); the U.S. Navy film "Destroyer Escort" (1943). All via the Internet Archive.
The animations, maps and diagrams were made for this video. Positions are schematic. Ground: GEBCO Compilation Group (2026) GEBCO 2026 Grid; Natural Earth; Terrain Tiles on AWS (ETOPO1).
#WW2 #UBoat #U869